Avi

word craft

blog

Achieving the Pinnacle

True Confessions of Charlotte DoyleA recent online review of one my books ref­er­enced The True Con­fes­sions of Char­lotte Doyle, as “the Pin­na­cle” of my writ­ing career. 

That book was pub­lished in 1990 and was my twen­ty-sec­ond book. 

Since that time—thirty years ago—I have pub­lished six­ty-one more books. 

Accept­ing the premise of the “pin­na­cle” as metaphor, does that mean I have been going down­hill these past thir­ty years? And, since the review­er was so cer­tain of Charlotte’s place among my books, is it fair to ask, were all my oth­er books read before mak­ing that judgement?

In truth I know of no one who has read all my books, and that includes my wife. I like to joke that not even I have read them all. 

It’s true there are many times I’ve been asked, “what’s my best book?” The sim­ple answer is: I don’t know. My way of eval­u­at­ing my own work is, “Did I achieve what I set out to do?” 

But there are many oth­er ways to eval­u­ate a writ­ers’ work: Copies sold? Copies read? Win­ner of most awards? Most adult-judged awards? Most children’s choice awards? Most ref­er­enced? Most crit­i­cal notice? Most used in schools? The book that gar­nish­es the most fan let­ters? The book my own kids think is best? Mind, you are wel­come to arrange these cat­e­gories in what­ev­er way you want (or add anoth­er), accord­ing to what you think is most important.

It’s safe to say that not one of my books meets all these criteria. 

I once asked a very famous writer why she didn’t write books any­more. She said: “Peo­ple tell me I’ve writ­ten the best book ever. Why should I both­er to write anoth­er? They won’t like it.” 

I have always thought that one of the sad­dest com­ments by a writer I’ve ever heard. 

Many a time online I’ve read side-by-side reviews of my books, one which says, “This is the best.” Anoth­er says, “This is the worst.” These are not objec­tive cri­tiques.

One of the great plea­sures of read­ing, I think, is that each of us makes a sub­jec­tive eval­u­a­tion of each book we read. It is a pow­er­ful per­son­al form of art. More­over, our response to a book may dif­fer accord­ing to the cir­cum­stance in which we read it. The book I read on a long flight may elic­it a dif­fer­ent reac­tion if read in the com­fort of my read­ing chair. The book I loved when I was twelve is not nec­es­sar­i­ly the book I loved when fifty. But the love at each time is real. 

How do we know if a par­tic­u­lar book is a good one? (Not nec­es­sar­i­ly the best.) If a lot of peo­ple like it for a lot of years.

Anoth­er ques­tion I’m often asked is, “What’s your own favorite book?” That answer I’m hap­py to give because it’s always true: “My favorite book is the one I’m work­ing on.” That’s because I’m try­ing to make it the best ever. 

Until I start a new one. 

My great hope is that my last book—whatever, when­ev­er that is—will be my best. 

You can decide. 

6 thoughts on “Achieving the Pinnacle”

    • So true! As Avi states, it is a per­son­al art, per­son­al expe­ri­ence, a per­son­al jour­ney. Each book is unique just as each reader/writer is unique. That’s the beau­ty of the writ­ten word- means some­thing dif­fer­ent for every­one who expe­ri­ences it from the author craft­ing it to the read­er who becomes absorbed in the text.

      Reply
  1. I love read­ing what­ev­er you write here and in your books. I can nev­er answer what my favorite book is in a gen­er­al way because I love and adore so many. I enjoy your blog so much and thank you again for your thought­ful, detailed and inter­est­ing posts here. PS I loved Char­lotte Doyle so I can see why the review­er loved it, but I agree about defin­ing or find­ing a pin­na­cle among such trea­sure. Keep writ­ing because you make a dif­fer­ence and you love it. And we are lucky.

    Reply
  2. Avi,
    It’s such a shame that Char­lotte isn’t rec­og­nized as a “strong female pro­tag­o­nist”. No, not real­ly. She’s strong in the most impor­tant way: moral conviction.

    Anoth­er way of judg­ing a book’s mer­it is by the qual­i­ty of its ideas. In that cat­e­go­ry, your work shines.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts