Avi

word craft

blog

This is not about writers’ block

SemiphoreI made my first class­room vis­it in 1970, short­ly after I pub­lished my first book, Things That Some­times Hap­pen. I can­not begin to num­ber the times I’ve been with kids in a class­room, be it in fact, or, these days, vir­tu­al­ly. One of the ques­tions I am almost always asked is, “Do you ever have writ­ers’ block?” I heard it just the oth­er day. 

Now, this is odd if you con­sid­er what Wikipedia notes about the condition: 

“Research con­cern­ing this top­ic was done in the late 1970s and 1980s. Dur­ing this time, researchers were influ­enced by the Process and Post-Process move­ments, and there­fore focused specif­i­cal­ly on the writer’s process­es. The con­di­tion was first described in 1947 by Aus­tri­an psy­cho­an­a­lyst Edmund Bergler,[9] who described it as being caused by oral masochism, moth­ers that bot­tle fed and an unsta­ble pri­vate love life.[8] The grow­ing rep­u­ta­tion of psy­chi­a­try in the Unit­ed States made the term gain more recog­ni­tion.[10]”  

Nev­er mind if this is true: Why would ele­men­tary stu­dents be ask­ing about such a thing? 

Because they are not real­ly ask­ing about writ­ers’ block. They are ask­ing a per­fect­ly rea­son­able ques­tion about the nor­mal process of writ­ing: get­ting stuck. 

Nobody—nobody—writes flaw­less work at one go. 

In all my years I have met only one writer who claimed he nev­er re-wrote any­thing. And he was a jour­nal­ist, who neglect­ed to men­tion that mul­ti­ple edi­tors always went over his writ­ing. So much for impec­ca­ble work. 

And why does this come to my mind today? 

As those of you who may have fol­lowed my blog posts of late, I have sus­tained a hip injury. No pain. No surgery. No pain med­ica­tion. Recov­ery is pre­dict­ed in four weeks or so. I can, and am, at my desk, writ­ing. BUT, it is hard for me to walk, and I am required to use a walk­er. What has this to do with writ­ing and writ­ers’ block? 

Because when I get stuck, I can’t just pop up and take a walk, wash the dish­es, sort my book­shelves, check the mail, file papers, etc. etc. etc. I have real­ized that my nor­mal pat­tern when think­ing out a writ­ing prob­lem, is get­ting up on my feet and doing some­thing. This is to say I take a break, shift my mind from my writ­ing to some­thing else, and then return to my words. And some­times, even when I’m doing those mind­less things I am work­ing out my problem. 

This is NOT about writ­ers’ block. This is the nor­mal flow of writ­ing. Get­ting stuck. Not sure about what hap­pens next. Who says what and how? 

(And at this moment, when I can’t pop up and take a break, it inter­feres with my writing!) 

Stu­dents often think they are doing poor­ly when their words don’t eas­i­ly flow from start to fin­ish. Since it nev­er will, it’s impor­tant for those of you who teach writ­ing, to stress the start and stop nature of writ­ing. That when they expe­ri­ence such a moment—and they always will—it is no dif­fer­ent than what every pro­fes­sion­al writer experiences. 

In oth­er words, when writ­ing, instead of using the phrase—“writers’ block—” use, “think­ing.” 

So, when stu­dents ask me the ques­tion, “Do you ever think about your writ­ing as you write?” they will know the answer before they ask. 

7 thoughts on “This is <em>not</em> about writers’ block”

  1. Oh, this is so smart. I hope a LOT of teach­ers are read­ing this. 

    That descrip­tion from 1947 was hor­ri­fy­ing. Freud has a lot to answer for …

    Reply
  2. I love your blog and your books. I am con­vinced that my son is an excel­lent writer because he grew up with your books. You enriched our lives with your beau­ti­ful writing…keep think­ing. You are great­ly loved by this fam­i­ly. @lilac_smd P.S. Hope your hip heals soon. You are lucky not to have pain.

    Reply
  3. So hap­py you are on the road to recov­ery. Thank you for your lat­est book, Loy­al­ty. The back and forth between the char­ac­ters, Noah and Jol­la, is rich with oppor­tu­ni­ties for stu­dent talk. What are the answers to their loy­al­ty dilem­ma? So much to think about. Almost makes me wish I were still in the class­room. Almost.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts